Everything you need to know about OCI, callbacks, compensation, and choosing between offers, written for students who are doing this for the first time.
BigLaw Bear · 10 min read

In this guide:
A summer associate program is a paid internship at a large law firm, typically 10 weeks between your 2L and 3L year. In practice, it is a 10-week job interview. Firms use it to decide whether to extend you a full-time offer. You use it to decide whether you actually want to work there.
The economics make sense for firms: recruiting and training a summer associate is expensive, but it is cheaper and less risky than lateral hiring. This is why BigLaw fills most of its talent pipeline through summer programs rather than hiring directly from the street.
As a summer, you will rotate through practice groups, work on real matters with supervision, and attend a lot of firm events. Offer rates at the end of the summer are typically above 90%, and some firms like Cravath are above 95%. The summer is less about whether you get an offer and more about whether you want to accept one.
That said, firms do no-offer summers every year, usually for professionalism problems or poor work quality. Show up prepared, treat everyone well, and take the work seriously.
This is the part most incoming students do not understand until it is too late: BigLaw recruiting is compressed, and it has gotten earlier.
The class that just finished 2L recruiting did OCI in January, three months into their first year of law school. Not spring. Not after they had found their footing. January.
Here is the realistic timeline for the 2026–2027 cycle:
A few firms (Kirkland & Ellis among them) have experimented with pre-OCI programs that effectively move the timeline even further forward. Check your school's career services calendar and watch for firm-specific early deadlines. These will catch you off guard if you are not paying attention.
1L recruiting is a different process. Fewer positions, less structure, and most openings are tied to diversity fellowships and pipeline programs. Skadden's 1L diversity program is the most well-known. Apply broadly if you are a 1L, but understand that the main event is 2L OCI. A strong 1L summer at a non-BigLaw employer (public interest, a judge's chambers, government) still gives you a credible story to tell during 2L recruiting.
Step 1: Build your bid list. Your school gives you access to a bidding platform (usually Symplicity or 12Twenty) with a list of participating firms. You rank or bid on firms you want to interview with. You will not get every firm you bid on, so treat it like college applications. Mix reach firms, targets, and safeties. Do this research before the window opens, not during it.
Step 2: Screening interviews (20 minutes). Short first-round interviews, mostly virtual at this point with a smaller number of in-person sessions still happening on campus. One or two attorneys from the firm. They are evaluating three things: Can you hold a conversation? Do you have genuine interest in the firm? Does your resume check out? These interviews are more about not losing than about winning. Be prepared, be personable, have a clear answer for "why this firm?"
Step 3: Callbacks. If they like you in the screener, you get invited to a callback. Format depends on the firm: some still bring you to the office for a half-day visit (they pay for travel), some run callbacks fully over Zoom, others use a hybrid model with a virtual first round and an in-person second look. Either way, you meet 3 to 6 attorneys over several hours, often including lunch or a casual chat with junior associates. This is where the actual hiring decision gets made. More on prep below.
Step 4: Offers. After callbacks, firms extend offers with decision windows, typically 28 days, though some firms push shorter timelines. NALP guidelines discourage exploding offers, but it happens.
Step 5: Decision. You evaluate your offers, attend second-look events, and choose. This part is harder than people expect.
Grades and law school. This is the threshold filter. T14 students with median grades will get screeners at most major firms. Students at schools ranked 15–50 generally need top 15–30% to be competitive at the most selective firms. Outside the T50, you need to be near the top of your class and bring something distinctive. This is not fair, but it is the reality, and pretending otherwise does not help you prepare.
Writing and research ability. Law review, moot court, and writing awards signal you can do the core work of a junior associate. If you are not on law review, find other ways to demonstrate. A strong writing sample from a clinic, a published note, a writing competition.
Prior experience. A career in finance, consulting, engineering, or government before law school is a real asset. Firms want people who have functioned in professional environments. Legal internships from 1L count here too.
Interpersonal skills. Every interviewer is asking themselves one question: would I want to work with this person at 11 PM on a Friday? Technical credentials get you the interview. Being someone people actually want to work with gets you the offer.
Genuine interest in the firm. This is where most students fall flat. Generic answers to "why this firm?" are a red flag. You need something specific: a practice area, a recent deal, a detail about the training model, something that shows you actually researched them. The firms that interview you have seen every version of "I was drawn to your collaborative culture." It does not land.
This is also the most fixable problem. If you spend real time with firm data before OCI (their Chambers rankings, their practice strengths, their summer program structure) you will have something substantive to say. The firm directory on BigLaw Bear is a useful place to start. Real data on 100 firms in one place, not 100 separate marketing websites.
Save this guide and compare firms from one free profile.
Create profileThe callback is where the decision gets made. Screenings are pass/fail. Callbacks are where firms compare you against other candidates. Here is what actually moves the needle:
Know the firm deeply. Recent deals or cases, key practice areas, strategic direction. Did they just launch a new group? Win a landmark case? Make a major lateral hire? Know these things. Read their press releases. Check the American Lawyer. Look up the attorneys you are meeting with beforehand.
Have your narrative ready. A coherent 90-second answer to "tell me about yourself": what you did before law school (if anything), why you chose law, why this firm. Not a script. A framework you can deploy naturally.
Prepare questions for each attorney. Look everyone up. If a partner does restructuring, ask about a recent deal. If a third-year associate just joined from a clerkship, ask about the transition. Do not ask things that are on the website. Do not ask about compensation.
Practice behavioral questions. "Tell me about a time you disagreed with a supervisor." "Describe managing competing deadlines." Have 3–4 stories you can adapt to different prompts. These come up constantly.
The small stuff. Arrive 10 minutes early. Bring extra resume copies. Dress conservatively. Send personalized thank-you emails within 24 hours to every attorney you met. These things are small but they separate otherwise identical candidates.
Summer associate pay is prorated from the first-year associate salary. The market is set by Cravath. When they move, most major firms follow within weeks.
Current Cravath scale (2026):
| Year | Annual salary |
|---|---|
| 1st | $225,000 |
| 2nd | $235,000 |
| 3rd | $260,000 |
| 4th | $295,000 |
| 5th | $335,000 |
| 6th | $365,000 |
| 7th | $385,000 |
| 8th | $415,000 |
At $225,000 annualized, a 10-week summer works out to roughly $43,000 before taxes. Most Cravath-scale firms also offer a bar stipend ($15,000–$20,000) when you start full time, and some offer signing bonuses of $5,000–$15,000.
Not every firm pays Cravath scale. Firms outside the AmLaw 50, especially in smaller markets, may pay below market. Always confirm directly with the firm. The compensation field on each firm's profile on BigLaw Bear shows the most recently reported data.
If you end up with multiple offers, here is how to think through the decision.
Practice area fit. At the junior associate level, your practice group determines your daily life more than the firm's overall brand. If you want to do restructuring, a firm known for M&A is not the right fit even if it is more prestigious on paper. Figure out where each firm is strongest in the areas you actually care about.
Training model. Firms vary a lot here. Some rotate you through groups in your first year. Others put you in a single group from day one. Some have structured mentorship; others leave it to you. Ask junior associates during your callback how they actually learned the job. Their answers will tell you more than any recruitment brochure.
Culture and hours. Every firm claims to value work-life balance. Look past the marketing. What are average billable hours in your target group? What is the attrition rate at three and five years? During your summer you will see a curated version of the firm, so get time with mid-level associates privately for a less filtered read.
Geography. Where you start concentrates your professional network. If you want to end up in Chicago long-term, starting in New York because it seems more prestigious may not serve you. Think about where you want to build a life.
Exit options. Some firms are better launch pads for specific paths. If you want to go in-house at a tech company, firms with active tech M&A practices in the right city matter. If you want government work, D.C. firms with white-collar practices have natural pipelines to DOJ and SEC. Think one step past the firm itself.
Compensation. Among Cravath-scale firms, pay is not a differentiator. If you are deciding between a Cravath firm and one below market, do the math honestly. But do not let $30,000 drive a decision that affects the next decade of your career if everything else points one direction.
Trust your gut, but verify it. Talk to people you trust. Reach out to associates at the firms you are considering through your alumni network. Make a decision you can explain with reasons, not just feelings.
Keep this guide handy.
Create a free profile to save articles, compare firms, and return to your recruiting plan.